Effective Engineering e-Newsletter – 5/08/2003
This is your bi-weekly e-Newsletter from Effective Engineering Consulting
If you would like to receive Effective Engineering e-newsletters as
they are published, please send an email to firstname.lastname@example.org,
and we will add you to our distribution list.
Are You Part of the Solution,
or Part of the Problem?
Tom Dennis – President, Effective Engineering [email@example.com]
Life in an engineering organization generally consists
of developing plans, implementing those plans, and confronting and overcoming
a seemingly never-ending series of problems by developing and implementing
creative solutions. When a team
is really clicking, implementing these solutions to problems can provide a
real sense of accomplishment. Everyone
is working closely together to achieve a common goal. Creative solutions arise from the interactions of ideas, and
one idea often becomes the springboard for an even better idea, and so on.
The final solution is generally far better than any of the individual
ideas because of the give and take and camaraderie that comes from working
well together as a team. The people involved in such efforts truly are part of the
solution. They leave their egos
outside the door, and put aside their individual concerns and frustrations to
work with their teammates to find the best way to get something done to solve
a pressing problem. It can be a
true joy to behold. It takes a
lot of effort for such a team to come together, but when it does, the team
becomes virtually unstoppable.
While this is clearly the most desirable outcome, all too often “teams”
far fall short of this result. Some
typical team killers include:
► Whiners (Constant Complainers):
Many “teams” contain whiners (would you like some cheese
with that whine?). These are
people who always see what’s wrong and seldom see what’s right, and seem
to delight in both pointing out what’s wrong and why the problems are
insurmountable. They seldom find
anything nice to say about anything or anybody. They are always pointing out why someone else’s suggested
approach can’t work, but never have their own suggestions on how to solve
the problem. They often actively
campaign against others’ suggestions or solutions, and fight success.
It is often their negative attitude that actually becomes one of the
key reasons that effective solutions are not found, and they certainly act as
significant demoralizers to the team. Whiners
excel at snatching defeat from the jaws of victory.
► Jellyfish (Meek Followers):
Another frequent “team” member is the jellyfish.
Jellyfish quiver with concern whenever any problems arises,
never seem to have their own ideas on how to solve problems, and seize upon
the first idea that another team member suggests, until another team member
suggests another idea, when they will drop support of the first and claim
support of the second. While they may have good skills in implementing what they are
told to work on, they are basically useless in solving unforeseen problems.
In fact, they often become an impediment to an effective solution
because they are always uncertain about what direction to move or what to do.
Jellyfish consume time, requiring repeated explanations, and are
constantly exclaiming, “the sky is falling”.
► Blowhards (Overbearing False Experts):
Heaven help the team with the blowhard.
Blowhards know absolutely what needs to be done, with no
ifs, ands, or buts. Their way is
the only way because they are the experts and you and the other team members
are mere peons who don’t really understand the complexities of the situation
in the way they do. They will
seldom even entertain others’ ideas, and will quickly put them down as
silly, misdirected, and wrong. If
you don’t do it their way, they will often go off and sulk in the corner and
refuse to have anything to do with the team.
Often, they don’t even recognize the impact of their behavior, as
they are so damn certain that they are right and everyone else is wrong.
Blowhards suck the air out of brainstorming discussions or
attempts to think creatively.
► Assassins (Underminers):
Assassins come to the party with their own agenda, and generally
their agenda is to advance themselves regardless of what it does to the group
or to the success of the organization. They
only want to make themselves look good, and all too often they feel they can
do this only by making others look bad. If
an assassin feels you have slighted them in any way, watch out. The knives are out, and you are the target.
The goals of the group become entirely secondary to getting revenge.
Assassins can be truly dangerous, sometimes even beyond the
► Others: We
can all identify other characteristics of people that destroy teamwork.
Learn to recognize other team destroyers.
What, then, can you do to change or discourage the team killers,
and turn them into successful, productive team members?
► Force team members to present approaches that can work rather
than simply complain about problems and why solutions can’t work.
No complaints should be accepted without proposed solutions; if team
members attempt this, send them away until they come back with some meaningful
ideas to solve the problems.
► Don’t accept the glass as half full or half-empty.
Instead, bring additional “water” to fill the glass to the top with
► A positive attitude is contagious.
A negative attitude can become contagious.
Therefore welcome, encourage, and even mandate positive attitudes, and
refuse to accept negative attitudes.
► Encourage team members to think outside the box, particularly when
things are looking grim. Brainstorm,
and find new approaches that others haven’t considered.
► If you can’t change the team killers, then let them know
they’re not welcome, and get them off the team.
It is imperative that teams successfully solve problems.
Everyone on the team must become part of the solution and not
part of the problem!
Copyright © 2003
Effective Engineering Consulting Services, All Rights Reserved